Bennet, Milton. “Over Coming the Golden Rule: Sympathy and Empathy”. New brunswick, NJ: Transactions Books, 1979. http://www.metfamily.org/agog/img/pdf/2011/Articles/Overcoming_Golden_Rule.pdf
This research log is a scholarly PDF file. It is about Sympathy and Empathy. The golden rule that this article speaks of is to “treat others as we would like to be treated”. The author Milton Bennet explains that this rule is what will bring international peace and intercultural understanding. He also says that the golden rule implies that everyone wants to be treated exactly the same, in that all people are exactly the same. If this is true then the golden rule is a fallacy, because everyone is individually different.
He then talks about how “the golden rule is a poor guide to communication.” On a philosophical level, he considers the assumption of similarity and its relationship to single realities. The communication idea he correlates with this is sympathy. Another thing in the philosophical level is the contrasting notion of assuming differences and its relationship to multiple realities. The communication idea linked to this is empathy.
With big emphasis he then explains the ideas of “the melting pot” and “ethnocentrism”. The melting pot concept is a course of concern to minorities in our country. Its also been thought my many that “the fusion of ethnic differences in America would lead to a great civilization of supermen.” However as the mainstream culture developed, the original idea of the melting pot changed to the ideal of assimilation and Americanization. The idea of ethnocentrism is the “tendency to see our own culture as the center of the universe affects all intercultural communication, including interethnic relations.”
Sympathy has advantages and disadvantages. He list advantages of sympathy. This includes, “Its easy”, “its credible”, “often accurate”, and its “comforting”. The disadvantages of sympathy are “its insensitive to differences”, “can be patronizing”, “breeds defensiveness”, and it “assumes similarities”. Bennet is not a huge fan of sympathy and doesn’t think it works. He does however like empathy. He talks about the steps in developing empathy by assuming differences, knowing yourself, suspending yourself, allowing imagination, reestablishing yourself, and then implementing it. He then changes the Golden rule into what he believes is a better motto to live by. The Platinum Rule: “do unto others as they themselves would have done unto them.”
I chose this article because I was really interested in the way Sennett had described sympathy and empathy in his book. I wanted to know what other people thought and if one was better than the other. I really like how Bennet in this article explains how to attain both and what can be an advantage or disadvantage of being sympathetic with someone. I for the most part agree with Bennet.